As we do not have the key for this lot we are unabel to say whether it winds properly. There are several faults to the dial - there is a crack at 9, chips to the outer edge at 11, 3 and between 12 & 1. The glass has quite a few scratches. There is a dent and discolouration to the back of the inner case and the case appears to have been forced open at some stage. There are also 2 small dents to the back of the outer case and a dent at the top of the front outer case